The National Audit Office's report on the Swedish Migration Agency's controls of work permits
The whole debate at riksdagen.se, in Swedish (opens in a new tab)
Translated from Swedish by AI; the translation may contain errors. The Swedish text is the original.
Speakers
Swedish Migration Agency work permit controls and audit report AI
1 S considers that Migrationsverket's controls are deficient, which increases labor exploitation and crime 1. S advocates for a government-based and needs-tested labor immigration where trade union parties are involved 1. 2 M argues that the government has worked hard to curb problems and that the focus on highly qualified labor reduces the risk of fraud 2. M considers that they have addressed the control of unscrupulous employers 2 and that these should be punished severely 3. 4 SD argues that labor immigration from the third world has been too poorly regulated 4. SD wants to clear out unscrupulous companies 5 and introduce barriers in the legislation 6. 7 V considers that deficiencies in controls increase the risk of wage dumping and work-life crime 7. V advocates for a return to government-based labor market assessment 7.
Written by AI in advance and may contain errors. The numbers lead to the speech a statement builds on; check against the text below.
The debate on the Riksdag's web TV (opens in a new tab)
The video, in Swedish, comes from the Riksdag's web TV and loads from riksdagen.se only when you click. The Riksdag may then count the playback in its visitor statistics.
Ola Möller (S)
Madam Speaker! The National Audit Office has audited the Swedish Migration Agency's controls of work permits. The audit shows that this work has not been effective. Deficiencies in the work risk increasing labor exploitation and unfair competition. Collectively, this also leads to more crime in the labor market.
Among other things, it is pointed out that work permits have been granted with employers who have previously been assessed as unreliable, without any in-depth investigation being conducted upon new applications. We Social Democrats have long pointed out this deficiency. We assert that a government-based labor market assessment, in collaboration with the parties in the labor market, would substantially reduce this abuse.
We also note that the petition which the Swedish Migration Agency sent to the Ministry of Justice in June 2025 regarding legislative changes aimed at strengthening the agency's control activities has so far not led to any concrete action regarding how long the unscrupulous employer remains in the system. This passivity deserves criticism in light of how much other migration policy and similar governance was delivered during this period. This should have been addressed, as it came from an agency as a petition.
This shows overall that we Social Democrats have a model that would be better for handling these issues, namely a government agency-based and means-tested labor immigration. The reason we want to introduce this model is that we want to prevent everything described in the report from occurring. Very many of the measures taken by the government have instead been about punishing those who do wrong, but it turns out that even that work is lacking.
With a government-based and means-tested labor immigration, where the trade unions and the employers' organization are involved in a more prominent way, one could stop this right here at the border. Then we do not get a situation where we need to punish these employers in hindsight and where people are subjected to exploitation.
The report is of course welcomed, but it is a distressing picture that is presented. We believe that further measures should have been taken to prevent this. Above all, the report is a confirmation that the model that we Social Democrats are pushing for is the right way to go.
Magnus Resare (M)
Madam Speaker! This is, of course, an important report. I like the reports from the Swedish National Audit Office. They are good at highlighting problems that occur in Swedish authorities and which need to be addressed and rectified. This is no exception. The report points out some problems that I heard about and experienced during the past parliamentary term and which I know the government has worked hard to curb.
I was at the Migration Agency a couple of years ago and learned how one of the country's largest hamburger restaurant chains had been subjected to attacks, or what it should be called, by persons who filled out that they would be employed within the chain. The chain was judged to be serious, which it also is. When, after two years, they are to check that everything has functioned well for the employee who came here, they are very questioning at the headquarters, because they do not have any such employee. It turns out that the person in question only went in and filled out the forms and cheated their way to a work permit. Then one does not know what has happened with the person, who has been here for a couple of years and been able to travel freely in Europe. One does not know if they have committed crimes or lived in other strange or bad ways. It is obvious that a very great abuse has occurred in these systems.
The report points out that there have been too poor controls and reviews of those who come here. It is not positive if people come here to work but do not work and instead abuse our systems. There is a risk of exploitation of people and that people come here for completely different purposes than to go to work.
I therefore think it is good that the government worked on the issue of labor immigration during the entire past parliamentary term. We have moved from having a strong focus on low-skilled labor to now bringing in more highly skilled labor. This in itself, I believe, will reduce the risk of this type of fraud; the type of employer who grants permits for highly skilled labor may be less inclined to cheat with the permits and establish sham employment or whatever it may be that challenges the Swedish labor market.
It is obvious that the government has taken action on this issue. In September, I had a meeting with the Swedish Migration Agency's work permit unit in Gothenburg. We talked about the concern regarding employers who are judged to be unserious and how one works further with them. They told me then that they have taken action on this, so that they now have good control over which employers in the country are judged to be unserious and that they can quickly deny them from bringing in more workers.
We also spoke about the fact that an employer who has at some point been judged to be unprofessional must reasonably be given the chance to show that they have improved and that the person or company can now offer decent jobs where there are not a lot of problems or risk of abuse. It is clear that some employers during the rest of their lives will be unsuitable to bring people in, for example if they have exploited people in a way that is not tolerable. But there will also be many employers with some minor deficiency that one needs to be given the chance to rectify.
I received good answers from the Swedish Migration Agency and perceived that they have truly taken hold of and started working on this issue to get the Swedish migration situation in order.
The government received the report and has been clear that they are actively working further on the issue. I believe that we in this chamber need to have a broad cooperation during the upcoming mandate period, regardless of which government takes office, and continue to work on these issues.
It is important for us in Sweden that the labor market is legally secure and that people who apply for work permits do not come here for reasons other than to work, because it must not be abused. When we have a need for workers in this country, the systems should not be flooded by people who believe it is a shortcut in to perhaps commit crimes or live outside of society in some other way.
Jessica Stegrud (SD)
Madam Speaker! Today we have a discussion on the National Audit Office's report on the Swedish Migration Agency's controls of work permits.
I will begin with a story from reality, Madam Speaker. I travel by taxi very often in the line of duty for understandable reasons, and I have a habit of asking almost all taxi drivers what the situation in the taxi industry is like right now. I find the question interesting from many aspects. The taxi industry is sensitive to economic cycles and very competitive, and I experience that the vast majority who work there have some form of immigrant background.
Taxi drivers meet many kinds of people and see different sides of our country today, and the answers I receive I see as a thermometer for everything from how the economy looks right now to how our country functions or does not function.
Over the past year, I have had many interesting discussions about everything from the spread of Islam in Sweden to the election we have just completed. The greatest impression was probably made by the discussion with a second-generation immigrant from Iraq who, when he found out that I was a politician, exclaimed: "You must do something about the taxi industry!"
When I asked what he was thinking about, he answered that it has become almost impossible to make a living. He often works twelve-hour shifts, sometimes up to six days a week. He has three children to support, but the margins have become incredibly small. One does not just compete with Uber and Bolt and so on, but also with labor migrants from third countries. He specifically mentioned taxi drivers from Pakistan.
I asked what the problem with that is – we introduced a wage floor a few years ago, which has also been raised now. He answered that it doesn't matter. Unserious employers register a large number of cars, probably far too many for the entire industry based on what is reasonable. On paper, the drivers have a salary of perhaps 34,000–35,000 a month, but then they have to pay back to the employer. Furthermore, perhaps ten people live in second, third, or fourth hand in a two-room apartment in Rosengård.
He said: "Jessica! You must do something about this. It doesn't work for those of us who are already here."
One might wonder why I bring up this particular anecdote, for it is indeed anecdotal evidence. I do it because it points to the problems we have today. We have a labor migration from third countries that has been far too poorly regulated. Now we have done a lot in this area. We have introduced a wage floor and have a number of requirements when it comes to family migration and so on, but the problems persist.
Madam Speaker! It must be remembered that the right to travel to Sweden, work here and build a future in our country is something that has a very great value for people all over the world, which is fully understandable. A work permit can mean an opportunity to support oneself, improve one's situation and, under certain conditions, bring one's family here and enjoy welfare and a security that one might not have had otherwise. In the longer term, it can also open the way to a permanent residence permit and ultimately Swedish citizenship.
Just this fact obviously opens up a market for unscrupulous employers – a market where people pay for employment and work permits and risk being subjected to labor exploitation and – in the most serious cases – human trafficking. It feeds the shadow society and makes it practically impossible to operate legally in certain industries. The taxi industry is just one example.
That is why this type of permit must be taken most seriously. We must be able to ensure that the work actually exists, that the employer is serious, that the wages are paid, and that the conditions underlying the decision also apply in reality, because when the state grants a work permit, it simultaneously makes a decision on who is allowed to stay in and work in our country.
Madam Speaker! Regulated migration requires that we have control over who comes to Sweden and on what grounds they come, as well as that the conditions for their permits are still met. It is about our country's ability to decide on its own development and to safeguard our labor market and our common resources, and about the trust in our authorities. It is also about protecting people from being exploited.
In order for us to understand how we have ended up in this situation, I want to speak briefly about political responsibility.
In 2008, the Moderate-led alliance government, in cooperation with the Green Party, opened up for labor migration. The authority-based labor market assessment was abolished. The employer's assessment was to govern the recruitment needs, even in occupations where there was already labor in Sweden.
The Social Democrats, who held power for eight years, maintained this basic model. They made certain tightenings, in the name of honesty, including requirements for employment contracts and subsistence requirements for accompanying family. The measures were introduced in 2022 – one might think it should have been obvious from the beginning. The basic order remained. Only during their final year in government did they appoint an inquiry into a means-tested labor migration, but it was not introduced during their time in government. Measures were taken, but they were not enough to resolve the problems.
Madam Speaker! I shall conclude by saying why we have another problem with this. Precisely the labor immigration that we see from the third world is all mostly low-skilled. At the same time, we have a labor market in Sweden with half a million unemployed, many of whom do not meet the requirements for the Swedish labor market today. First and foremost, it is low-skilled labor that finds no matching on the labor market. To then supplement with low-skilled labor immigration from the third world is not the recipe for a successful country and a functioning labor market in Sweden.
It has been tightened, and much has been done even during this mandate period. We are the guarantor that there will be order and clarity in Swedish migration policy, and we will continue to be that in the coming years, regardless of government.
I welcome the report and take for granted that the measures, which are needed to resolve the remaining problems, will be pushed through.
Ola Möller (S)
Madam Speaker! Thank you for the speech, Member Stegrud!
It is interesting that the taxi industry is being brought up here. We have read that Tobias Andersson, who is a party colleague of Jessica Stegrud, takes many taxis in his official capacity in the Riksdag. He is clear that he travels with Uber or Bolt. There are no collective agreements there, but it concerns precisely the groups that Jessica Stegrud points to with her whole hand. She says that they come from the third world, that they are exploited, and that they drive for wages that lead to low prices, which destroys the Swedish taxi industry.
Now we see that additional companies are on their way to Sweden. Apparently, some billionaire in Vietnam is going to establish a huge amount of taxis here. The probability that collective agreements will be signed is quite low, and the risk is that we end up in a Tesla-like situation. In that, the aforementioned Andersson stood on Tesla's side and thought that collective agreements should not be signed.
My question to Member Stegrud is: How does Member Stegrud view the fact that people travel with Bolt and Uber, which are breaking down the taxi industry in the way Member Stegrud described here?
Jessica Stegrud (SD)
Madam Speaker! Thank you, Member, for the question!
Now, that is not the primary reason why the taxi market looks the way it does. The serious taxi drivers have this competition from third countries, which work under completely unreasonable conditions. So it shouldn't be that way. We have raised the limit with the wage floor, which really is a step forward. Had the Social Democrats' model been applicable, it would have looked even worse.
I think that the serious taxi companies should be favored. It should not be possible to cheat one's way into a work permit when one arrives here. It must be removed. The unserious taxi companies must be cleared out from the market. The controls must become much better. On that, we are in complete agreement.
When it comes to the gig economy, or whatever we are going to call it, I am not well-versed in that issue, but I believe we are falling under EU legislation. My firm conviction is that Sweden is a country that, above all, does not need taxi drivers from Pakistan, India, or Bangladesh. We have, as I mentioned, a labor market with hundreds of thousands with low education who are far from the labor market.
It can be a first step into the labor market to start working as a taxi driver in Sweden when one is already here, when one has a residence permit or is even born here and has citizenship. We think that is the most important reform to take with us.
Ola Möller (S)
Madam Speaker! I note that I receive no answer as to why leading Sweden Democrats are traveling with just those drivers that Member Stegrud points out, so we shall proceed.
Regarding legislation for the EU, I wonder about the EU directive called the single permit and the referral to the Council of Legislation that the government – and also the Sweden Democrats, I assume – stood behind. It is about how a labor migrant from a third country should be able to enter Sweden and already then change jobs, immediately upon entering the Swedish labor market, simply via a notification to the Migration Agency. Given the enormously lacking controls that the National Audit Office's report has shown, I wonder how the Sweden Democrats can agree to that from day one when one has entered Sweden, one should be able to change employers.
This directive enables waiting periods and also longer review periods – 45 days of review time and 90 days I believe it is, no, nine months before one can change employers for the first time. Does Member Stegrud mean that the Sweden Democrat position is that it is a reasonable path that one, as a labor migrant, should be able to change employers from day one only via a notification to Migrationsverket, given what comes out in the National Audit Office's review? It will, of course, mean that the important thing is that one gets into Sweden. It is obviously quite simple, according to the National Audit Office's report, if one only knows how to do it. And then one should be able to change jobs directly. If anything, that will shatter everything that Member Stegrud is standing here and speaking so warmly for.
My question is: Will the Sweden Democrats maintain the position they have had so far regarding the single permit directive, or will the Sweden Democrats side with what we Social Democrats are pushing for, that is, that we should utilize the waiting periods that exist in the directive?
Jessica Stegrud (SD)
Madam Speaker! I can make a long list of Social Democratic representatives who take both Uber and Bolt around the country, so it would be a bit trivial if I were to stand here and explain why a Sweden Democrat representative chooses to do so. He can simply answer that himself.
When it comes to the single permit, it is an EU directive, which actually should have already been introduced. There is a reason why it is not, and that is that the Sweden Democrats in particular have tried to drag it out. It is completely true. We also think that the current order is unreasonable. It is admittedly an EU directive, but we think there should be barriers. We can actually introduce barriers in the Swedish legislation even though it is fundamentally an EU directive that we need to follow.
The Social Democrats have a great fondness for the EU. When I sat in the European Parliament, reform after reform was voted through, everything that moves power down to Brussels, so that one now stands here and complains about a directive that we ultimately have to implement is actually quite fascinating.
I will nevertheless give the member an insight: We are actually in this issue a bit more in agreement with just you Social Democrats than with the previous Tidö government. But, as the member knows, in a cooperation one sometimes – or very often – needs to compromise.
That is also why we do not see any new government in place. The member's party fails to gather the so-called winning team, so this appears as a rather small schism in relation to much else.
Jennifer Merelaid Hankins (V)
Madam Speaker! A well-functioning labor migration can contribute a great deal to the individual and to the Swedish economy and labor market. This presupposes, in the Left Party's view, order and clarity in the labor market and respect for applicable laws, conditions, and collective agreements.
When the review of the Swedish Migration Agency's controls of work permits was published, the National Audit Office commented: "The deficiencies increase the risk of wage dumping and distorted competition, where serious companies are disadvantaged. They also create a breeding ground for crime in the labor market and labor exploitation."
It is about companies that have been repeatedly denied work permits nevertheless having received new permits. In several of these cases, the companies have been considered unscrupulous. They have had sham employments or even forged trade union statements. These are, therefore, highly harmful behaviors that affect both employees and the Swedish labor market as a whole. This is a consequence of the lax policy regarding labor immigration that has been conducted for many years and which obviously benefits unscrupulous employers who exploit people.
The Government agrees with the National Audit Office's criticism and accounts for a number of measures it has taken or will take, which is good and welcome. We look forward to further measures. But it also raises a larger question. Why do we, at regular intervals year after year, receive alarm reports about problems with employers who abuse the system?
The question of companies abusing work permits is in no way new. Problems with unscrupulous employers who exploit people have recurred for many years, certainly nearly two decades. Several previous governments have introduced measures that have periodically reduced parts of the problems, but now we stand here again with an audit showing risks of wage dumping, labor crime, and exploitation. Obviously, patching and repairing a flawed system has not been sufficient. It may be time to consider a different system.
Vänsterpartiet has for many years advocated for a return to authority-based labor market assessment, a means-tested assessment where the parties in the labor market are involved. To achieve order and clarity in the labor market and strengthen the position of employees, more measures are needed, for example, to further strengthen the possibilities for labor migrants who come forward and report about poor conditions at the employer to stay and have good conditions to seek a new job, so that we bring these problems to the surface. We also want to introduce the possibility of damages for the employee who is affected.
We in Vänsterpartiet are convinced that measures targeting the one who exploits – the perpetrator, so to speak – have greater significance than much of what the government has devoted its full strength to in recent years to deter or deport people who work in Sweden, for example, abolishing track changes without transitional rules and creating impossible wage requirements that lead to necessary and competent labor being deported.
The Swedish Migration Agency is drowning in the current government's numerous legislative changes, where it seems to be a priority to jeopardize the residence permits of honest people. With the government's deportation policy, it is therefore not so strange if the work of controlling work permits ended up lower on the priority list.
We in Vänsterpartiet believe that other tightenings of the legislation are needed to create a fair system for labor migration. The focus should be on countering exploitation and abuse, not on generally restricting immigration to Sweden or making it harder for those who have already sought out our country. It should be the labor market's needs that guide labor migration, not the right-wing government's desires for reduced immigration or neoliberal dreams of cheap labor.
Magnus Resare (M)
Madam Speaker! Thank you, the member, for the speech!
I experience that the member directed their speech very strongly towards employers and did not open up for the discussion that exists regarding employees who make mistakes.
I know that the member's own colleague here in the Riksdag has cheated quite a bit with his CV. In recent weeks and months, it has been noted how he has claimed to have worked with both the one and the other. It is one of many flaws in that person's character, but it is not exactly the subject of debate today.
But with that as the approach and against the background of what the member said here in the speaker's chair, I just wonder: How does the member mean that we should behave if an employee with a family here turns out to have mismanaged their work permit and cheated, lied, or not gone to work? The family has established themselves here in Sweden while the person held this work permit. Can it be okay to deport a family with children if it turns out that the person who held the work permit actually cheated?
There are, in fact, two perspectives in this issue. There are employers who exploit people, and we agree that this must stop and that they should be punished severely. But I wonder if we also agree that the employee who cheats should be deported from the country.
Jennifer Merelaid Hankins (V)
Madam Speaker! Thank you, Member, for the question!
If employees commit irregularities or violate laws and regulations, it shall be investigated and prosecuted just like all other irregularities. Consequences shall then follow according to current legislation.
Magnus Resare (M)
Madam Speaker! In that case, I have received an answer, even though I do not think the answer was as developed as I would have liked after the focus the member had when she portrayed employers as the only group in society that has shortcomings. I believe that there are also individuals who make mistakes.
The vast majority of those who come to this country and work do so in a way that is right and proper, and that is positive. It contributes to our welfare and the ability of Swedish companies to grow. But there are also those who commit errors, and then I wonder if the member thinks there are problems with deporting persons who do not follow the permit they have.
Jennifer Merelaid Hankins (V)
Madam Speaker! As said, if an offense is committed by a person who has a work permit, it must be investigated and, if it is a crime, prosecuted according to current legislation.
The deliberation was hereby concluded.
Source: The Swedish Parliament. The speeches come from the open data of the Riksdag, translated into English by AI, which may contain errors.
Portraits: Photo: The Swedish Parliament. (opens in a new tab)