Kammarkoll

Search everything said in the debates of the Swedish Riksdag

, to the start page

← To the search

The National Audit Office's report on the state's work to counter risks of ethnic discrimination in agency decisions

18 November 2026 · 27 speeches · S, SD, MP, V, M, C, KD

The whole debate at riksdagen.se, in Swedish (opens in a new tab)

Translated from Swedish by AI; the translation may contain errors. The Swedish text is the original.

Speakers

Ethnic discrimination in agency decisions: Riksrevisionen report AI

S welcomes the Swedish National Audit Office's report but expresses concern over deficiencies in the authorities' preventive work and advocates for expanded anti-discrimination protections 1. SD emphasizes that decisions must be based on objective grounds and legal certainty, not origin 2, and argues that Swedish nationality must be included in reports to ensure equal treatment 3 4 5. V argues that ethnic Swedes have priority 6, that the authorities' work is insufficient 7, and that the report is correct as it is based on current grounds 8. M believes that individuals should be assessed as individuals 9. MP wants to introduce equality data 10 and emphasizes the intersectional perspective 11. C emphasizes the importance of practical measures and routines 12. KD welcomes the review and wants to see stronger work against ageism 13.

Written by AI in advance and may contain errors. The numbers lead to the speech a statement builds on; check against the text below.

How the Riksdag voted

What does this mean?

The committee is a group of members from all parties that prepares the matter and proposes what the Riksdag should decide, in a report. Parties in the committee that want something else write a reservation, a proposal of their own.

The Riksdag then votes on each part on its own. The heading says what the part is about. When it is Avslag på propositionen (rejection of the bill) it is about a call to reject the whole proposal, and the committee's proposal won then means the proposal was not rejected but went through. For the committee's proposal and against are how each party's members voted; against usually means for a reservation. Split means the party's members voted differently, and abstained that they voted for neither.

Independents are members who have left their party, or been expelled, and stay without one. The Riksdag writes it as (-). They vote one by one, so for them the numbers are shown.

Hover over a party to see how many voted which way.

Skrivelse om risker för etnisk diskriminering vid myndigheters beslut har behandlats (AU3)

Riksdagen har behandlat en skrivelse från regeringen som bygger på Riksrevisionens rapport om statens arbete för att motverka etnisk diskriminering vid myndigheters beslut som rör enskilda. Riksdagen poängterar att etnisk diskriminering är ett allvarligt samhällsproblem som kräver ett långvarigt, samordnat och målmedvetet arbete. Riksrevisionen har motiverat sin granskning med att det funnits tecken på att etniska diskriminering förekommer vid myndigheters beslut som rör enskilda. I granskningen har det framkommit att statens arbete inte är effektivt när det gäller att motverka etnisk diskriminering. Regeringen presenterar i skrivelsen de åtgärder som man gjort utifrån Riksrevisionens iakttagelser. Regeringen har gett Diskrimineringsombudsmannen, DO, i uppdrag att genomföra riktade insatser till myndigheterna om hur man i den egna verksamheten kan motverka etnisk diskriminering. Riksdagen välkomnar regeringens uppdrag till DO och lägger skrivelsen till handlingarna, vilket innebär att ärendet avslutades.

Principen om likabehandling vid myndigheters beslut The committee's proposal won.

271 for61 against17 absent

  • For the committee's proposal: Social Democrats, Moderates, Centre Party, Left Party, Christian Democrats, Liberals, Green Party
  • Against: Sweden Democrats

Spoke for the parties in the debate

What was decided without a vote is not shown. Source: The Swedish Parliament.

The debate on the Riksdag's web TV (opens in a new tab)

The video, in Swedish, comes from the Riksdag's web TV and loads from riksdagen.se only when you click. The Riksdag may then count the playback in its visitor statistics.

Speakers (27)
  1. Katarina Berggren (S)
  2. Sara Gille (SD)
  3. Bassem Nasr (MP)
  4. Sara Gille (SD)
  5. Bassem Nasr (MP)
  6. Sara Gille (SD)
  7. Ciczie Weidby (V)
  8. Sara Gille (SD)
  9. Ciczie Weidby (V)
  10. Sara Gille (SD)
  11. Amanda Thonander (M)
  12. Bassem Nasr (MP)
  13. Amanda Thonander (M)
  14. Bassem Nasr (MP)
  15. Amanda Thonander (M)
  16. Ciczie Weidby (V)
  17. Sara Gille (SD)
  18. Ciczie Weidby (V)
  19. Sara Gille (SD)
  20. Ciczie Weidby (V)
  21. Helena Vilhelmsson (C)
  22. Sara Gille (SD)
  23. Helena Vilhelmsson (C)
  24. Sara Gille (SD)
  25. Helena Vilhelmsson (C)
  26. Veronica Kerr (KD)
  27. Bassem Nasr (MP)

Katarina Berggren (S)

Madam Speaker! Now we shall speak about a serious social problem: discrimination, with a particular focus on ethnic discrimination.

As a social democrat, I want an inclusive society free from discrimination. It is my Sweden.

In 2024, the Equality Ombudsman received approximately 4,400 reports of discrimination on one or more grounds. According to survey studies, between 600,000 and 1 million people in Sweden experience discrimination every year. This means that only a small proportion of those who experience discrimination also report it.

A consistent pattern in survey results is that younger people, particularly women aged 16–29, as well as people born outside of Europe, are overrepresented among those who state that they have been subjected to discrimination. It can be about background, culture, and social or economic conditions.

Discrimination can take forms such as racist comments or harassment in school or at the workplace. It can involve deprioritization within healthcare due to ethnic background or longer processing times or outright rejections from authorities due to name or appearance.

Madam Speaker! Now to the Swedish National Audit Office's audit report 2026:8. We Social Democrats welcome the report but are simultaneously concerned about the serious deficiencies identified, with the conclusion that the state's work is not effective regarding the work against ethnic discrimination in decisions concerning individuals.

It is obvious that the work against discrimination must be evaluated. It is a serious societal problem that requires long-term, coordinated and purposeful work. Every agency in Sweden has a responsibility to strive for equal treatment and counteract discrimination in all its activities. At the same time, the National Audit Office now states that there are indications that ethnic discrimination occurs in several state agencies' decisions regarding different types of support, controls, or interventions.

The audit report lying on the Riksdag's table shows that the seven agencies included in the audit do indeed have a good preparedness to act based on reports concerning ethnic discrimination, which is good. On the other hand, it is noted that there are deficiencies, primarily in the agencies' preventive work. These deficiencies in the preventive work create, as the Swedish National Audit Office expresses it, "a tangible risk that problems are not detected and addressed."

This is not acceptable, Madam Speaker. The goal must be a Sweden free from discrimination. The ambition cannot be lower than that.

An important prerequisite for reducing segregation and increasing integration is to work effectively to counter risks of ethnic discrimination. Therefore, the Riksrevisionen's audit is an important contribution to the work.

We Social Democrats welcome the recommendations that the Swedish National Audit Office has submitted to the government regarding following up on whether state agencies investigate and manage risks of ethnic discrimination in their decisions affecting individuals, as well as increasing competence regarding methods for investigating risks of ethnic discrimination. Furthermore, it is proposed that the Equality Ombudsman shall ensure that training and dialogues are directed to state agencies to a greater extent in order to drive their preventive work against ethnic discrimination in decisions.

We from the Social Democrats note that the Tidö government has not done enough in this area. Ambition and will seem to be lacking. We assess that further measures are needed, for example, that the protection against discrimination in the legislation is expanded.

Not taking this social problem seriously involves a risk that the individual will be affected and lose rights and opportunities, for example, important interventions to get into work. It also risks that trust in authorities and the democratic values that our society rests on will be undermined.

In conclusion, we as politicians and elected representatives must take responsibility for and consider how we express ourselves. We must express ourselves in a way that does not cause our fellow human beings to risk falling into further racism and discrimination.

Madam Speaker! I vote in favor of the committee's proposal in report AU3.

(Applause)

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! It is a bit extra special that it is just Madam Speaker who is here, as she has also sat in our committee.

I would like to begin by moving for approval of the Sweden Democrats' reservation under point 2.

Whoever turns to a Swedish authority must be able to rely on the fact that the decision is made on objective grounds. It must be the law and the circumstances in the individual case that decide, and not the person's name, origin, or ethnic affiliation. It is a fundamental part of the rule of law. People must be able to trust that the authorities do their job correctly and fairly. When that trust is breached, confidence in the state is damaged.

The National Audit Office's review shows that the state's work against ethnic discrimination is not functioning sufficiently well. It is remarkable. The work is largely event-driven. This means that the authorities often act only when problems have arisen instead of working in a preventive manner to be able to prevent them. The National Audit Office also points out deficiencies in the preventive work and notes that the Discrimination Ombudsman's opportunities to drive development are limited.

Madam Speaker! This is a serious criticism. The authorities have their own responsibility to investigate whether there are risks of discrimination in their activities. They should not wait for a report before they begin to review their own routines.

It requires long-term work for deficiencies to be discovered and be able to be corrected, and it must happen in time. Otherwise, the problems risk continuing and escalating while people have to bear the consequences of the authorities' failures. However, it is not enough to do more. We must also ensure that the measures hit the mark.

Madam Speaker! The National Audit Office addresses, among other things, the possibilities of comparing the authorities' decisions for groups with different ethnic backgrounds. Such comparisons can be very valuable. They can show where there is reason to investigate whether people are being treated differently.

But here we must also stick to the facts. That two groups receive different results does not automatically mean that anyone has been discriminated against. There can be other explanations. People can have different circumstances, and their cases can differ in several different ways. Therefore, we must investigate the causes before we conclude that it is a matter of discrimination. We should not be too quick with that.

Drawing far-reaching conclusions solely based on statistics is not serious. It can lead to incorrect assessments and measures that do not solve the real problems. In that case, we risk using the authorities' resources in the wrong way. We should, of course, have high demands on the authorities, but we must also set high demands on the underlying data and methods used to review their work.

Madam Speaker! In the Swedish National Audit Office's report, among other things, Roma and persons of African and Asian origin are mentioned. The report also presents the government's action plan against racism and hate crimes. In it, Muslims, Jews, persons of African descent, Roma, and Sámi are highlighted as particularly vulnerable. On the other hand, people of Swedish origin are not highlighted in a corresponding way. It stands out. It is noteworthy, and we miss that part.

Sverigedemokraternas starting point is obviously that protection against discrimination shall apply to everyone, even those who are disadvantaged because of their Swedish affiliation. It is the individual's rights that shall stand at the center.

Madam Speaker! The Government has tasked the Equality Ombudsman with helping the authorities to identify and manage risks of ethnic discrimination. It is a measure intended to address the deficiencies that the National Audit Office has highlighted.

Our motion is about the work being based on the individual and the principle of equal treatment. It is a clear and reasonable starting point. For the Sweden Democrats, it is not just about talking about legal certainty and equal treatment. These principles must also take effect in how the authorities actually work.

It must be clear what mandate the authorities have. They must make correct decisions according to applicable law. They must be able to explain their assessments, and they must stand by the decisions that are made.

Madam Speaker! When someone is treated incorrectly, there must be an opportunity to have the decision reviewed. When the authorities fail in their routines, these must be corrected.

The Swedish National Audit Office's criticism shows that formal requirements and internal governance documents are not enough. Follow-up is also needed on how the agencies' work functions and whether measures are taken when there are shortcomings, in order for things to be right and for a good result to be achieved. Ultimately, it is about the state's responsibility to ensure that the rule of law is upheld in practice.

Madam Speaker! The Sweden Democrats do not demand that all people should get the same results, but we demand that they should be treated according to the same principles. If one mentions a group, one must also mention other groups. That is what our reservation is about. It is a principle that should apply fully, even for those who are Swedish. I move again for approval of reservation 2.

riksdagen.se

Bassem Nasr (MP)

Madam Speaker! In the Swedish National Audit Office's report, it is described that people coming from different minority groups run a greater risk of having their applications rejected and being subjected to incorrect controls – this regardless of what the Sweden Democrats say about discrimination not existing. What political proposals do the Sweden Democrats have to protect Swedes with an immigrant background from discrimination?

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! We are not saying that discrimination does not exist. The member cannot come here and claim that, because it is not true. It is clear that discrimination exists, but it is remarkable when one mentions discrimination of certain groups but does not mention those with Swedish ethnicity, those who have Swedish origin. But of course, discrimination exists. I do not understand that comment at all.

riksdagen.se

Bassem Nasr (MP)

Madam Speaker! Just a moment ago, the member in the speaker's chair said that we should not be in too much of a hurry to say that it is discrimination and that there can be different reasons why two groups receive different results; it does not have to be about discrimination. In this report, however, one still lands on the conclusion that the state of knowledge indicates that the risk of receiving poorer service and more rejections and being subjected to incorrect controls is greater for people who have origins in, for example, Africa or Asia.

All equal value is established in the Swedish constitution, as the member knows. Protection against discrimination exists in our legislation. I assume that the Sweden Democrats want Swedish law to apply in Sweden and be fully respected. So, again: What political proposals do the Sweden Democrats have to protect Swedes with an immigrant background from discrimination?

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! The member is rushing completely when it comes to this. We have never said that discrimination does not exist. That was not what I said from the rostrum. I believe that the member simply would need to listen to my speech once more. Drawing conclusions too quickly does not mean that one excludes the other. Discrimination exists – yes. But to go directly to that point, we do not think is serious. There can be other reasons as well.

Then we think it is very remarkable that it is not pointed out that even Swedes, those of Swedish origin, can be discriminated against.

Of course, Swedish law shall apply. Everyone's equal value is a self-evident fact. In contrast to the Green Party, it is this that the Sweden Democrats actually advocate for and promote. I think it is very absurd that this comes from a member who belongs to a party that does not itself promote that issue.

We talk about everyone's equal value regardless of where you come from. But if one writes in a report or an account that it concerns people of African origin or that it concerns Muslims, Roma or Sámi and so on, we think it is strange that one does not also talk about Swedish belonging – about people who are born and raised in Sweden. It is, in fact, a very important part.

riksdagen.se

Ciczie Weidby (V)

Madam Speaker – perhaps the world's best Speaker! Thank you so very much, Sara Gille, for your speech!

I have, of course, read the Sverigedemokraterna's follow-up motion and listened to Sara Gille's speech in the debate here. I was struck by that Sara Gille said that one cannot draw conclusions from statistics. The member would be very welcome to elaborate on that. I know that the member Sara Gille often speaks about, for example, men's violence against women and that issue. There is a huge amount of statistics there that one leans on in order to be able to map out and see who is being targeted and so on. I would very much like to know what different conclusions one can or cannot draw from statistics.

Then it also becomes interesting, because what is important for the Sweden Democrats but which doesn't quite come across here is how one views the individual versus the collective. That is the running point here. As I understand it, the Sweden Democrats do not believe in structural discrimination, but it is only about discrimination of individual persons. I cannot reconcile this. If one cannot speak about the existence of groups that are structurally disadvantaged or discriminated against, why is it then so important for the Sweden Democrats that the group ethnic Swedes should be included in the groups that are discriminated against, something I know they have fought for for a long time? Please do explain that!

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! Thank you to the member for the question!

It is clear that we take the National Audit Office's criticism very seriously. But when it comes to statistics, they can show differences, and this must, of course, be investigated – that is not what we are referring to. But the fact that there are statistical differences does not automatically mean that it is a matter of discrimination. It does not have to be discrimination because of that. We think that the authorities should start from the individual, quite simply.

Then I do not understand why we should not be able to mention Swedish affiliation. Why should we not be able to mention that one can be discriminated against because of having Swedish descent? In this report, African descent is mentioned, as well as Roma and Muslims. Both religion and origin are addressed. Why then can Swedish affiliation not be mentioned? Why can it not be mentioned that the one who has grown up in Sweden and belongs to Sweden can be discriminated against, when both religion and origin in different countries are mentioned? Why then can the Swedes not be mentioned? I do not understand this. I do not understand why it is so sensitive for the Vänsterpartiet to actually mention it. I would very much like to know what the member considers regarding this.

We believe that discrimination should apply to all groups. If one group is mentioned, one should also be able to mention the other. This is very important.

riksdagen.se

Ciczie Weidby (V)

Madam Speaker! I know that the Sweden Democrats want ethnic Swedishness to be included in the grounds for discrimination, which means that you believe there is structural discrimination on certain grounds, but it should only apply if ethnic Swedes are also included among the groups you list. If ethnic Swedes are not included there, there is also no discrimination against the other groups. The reasoning does not hold up, and this is what the Sweden Democrats can never resolve or explain.

It is not only Vänsterpartiet that is against this. The other parties do not think either that ethnic Swedes should be included here. The Sverigedemokraterna know this too, because otherwise they would have received approval for their diligent motions during at least the eight years I have sat in this committee.

It does not have to be due to discrimination; there can be objective explanations. What objective explanations would they be? It could, of course, be that Kalle Svensson is a bad person and should not have the job. Do the Sverigedemokraterna think there should be a special file just for ethnic Swedes? Can the Sverigedemokraterna and Sara Gille not see that there actually is discrimination in Sweden and on the Swedish labor market that disadvantages people who are not ethnic Swedes? Ethnic Swedes always have priority in the country Sweden. It is the other groups that are being discriminated against. Why can the Sverigedemokraterna not see and acknowledge it?

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! We are not saying that they are not discriminated against. It is clear that we acknowledge that there is discrimination against all groups. I do not understand why the member comes up with something such as that. It is clear that all groups can be discriminated against.

What we lack is precisely that those of Swedish origin are not included in the text. All groups can be discriminated against, absolutely. We are not opposing that, but I do not understand why the member and her party simply cannot acknowledge that Swedes too – people who are born and raised in Sweden – can also be discriminated against. Why are they not allowed to be included in this report and in all other reports? Why are they not allowed to be included in Vänsterpartiet's thoughts at all?

I think that if anything, it is discrimination. What the Left Party is doing is precisely to discriminate against Swedes – people with Swedish ethnicity.

It is clear that discrimination shall apply to all groups. That is how it is, and we do not oppose that.

riksdagen.se

Amanda Thonander (M)

Madam Speaker! In Sweden, all individuals shall be judged just as individuals. This is a self-evident matter for both me and the Moderaterna. Discrimination is unacceptable regardless of the grounds. This is a fundamental principle in a free society, but it is particularly important in the encounter between the individual human being and the state. The state has a power that no one else has. Authorities make decisions daily that have far-reaching consequences for people's lives. Therefore, we must also set very high demands on how that power is exercised.

Anyone who turns to a Swedish authority should, of course, be able to trust that they will be treated objectively, impartially, and fairly. Therefore, the National Audit Office's review is very welcome. The National Audit Office has reviewed how seven state authorities work to counter risks of ethnic discrimination in administrative decisions. The conclusion is that the work is not sufficiently effective. This is criticism that we take very seriously and that one must take seriously.

The authorities simultaneously have a fairly good preparedness to handle the reports of discrimination that come in, but the preventive work is not sufficiently systematic. The measures rarely build on analyses of the risks in their own operations, and the follow-up is insufficient. This means that the authorities do not always have sufficient knowledge of where the risks are or which measures actually work.

At the same time, it is important to emphasize that all government agencies already have a responsibility to counteract discrimination in their activities. It is not a new task that is to be placed on the agencies, but it is a responsibility that they already have and that they must become better at fulfilling. The responsibility cannot be limited to handling the reports that come in if something has gone wrong. One must work more preventatively.

The National Audit Office's review shows that the work needs to improve. It is about the authorities being able to identify the risks in their own decision-making processes, take relevant measures, and follow up on whether the measures themselves are working.

Madam Speaker! The Government has taken the Swedish National Audit Office's criticism seriously. The Equality Ombudsman has, among other things, been tasked with carrying out targeted measures to strengthen the authorities' work in investigating and managing risks of ethnic discrimination. It is also about improving the authorities' knowledge and developing methods that can actually be used in their operations.

In addition to this, it is part of the assignment to monitor risks linked to artificial intelligence and automated decision-making. This is very important, because the same requirements for objectivity must, of course, apply regardless of how a decision is made at the authorities.

The government's measures are important steps, but the work must truly be followed up and continue forward. With this, Madam Speaker, I move for approval of the committee's proposal for a decision.

In this speech, Olle Olson and Oliver Rosengren (both M) agreed.

riksdagen.se

Bassem Nasr (MP)

Madam Speaker! I want to start by thanking Member Amanda Thonander for her speech and clear stance against discrimination and that this issue is prioritized. I believe that many of those who are sitting at home and listening to this, especially those with a different ethnic background, greatly appreciate that the Member is so clear on these issues.

I would like to ask three questions to Member Thonander: 1. How high has the trust of young Roma in the justice system been over time? 2. How do academics with an immigrant background experience meetings with Arbetsförmedlingen? 3. What percentage of Black women have great or very great trust in maternity care?

I wonder if the member can answer these three questions and, if not, if she is interested in receiving answers to them.

riksdagen.se

Amanda Thonander (M)

Madam Speaker! I do not intend to participate in any interrogation, but if it is the case that the member wishes to discuss these issues, he is of course warmly welcome to present what he wishes to present. Then we can discuss the issue at hand.

riksdagen.se

Bassem Nasr (MP)

Madam Speaker! This is not a mock trial. I do not know the answers either, because this statistics does not exist. Therefore, the Green Party wants to introduce equality data. It is statistics based on different grounds of discrimination, such as religion, ethnicity, and disability. It shall, of course, be collected entirely voluntarily, anonymously, and through self-identification.

One of the reasons that Sweden has come as far as we actually have in the work on equality is that we have gender-disaggregated statistics so that we can measure the development over time and analyze which measures make a real difference. We could have done the equivalent for people who belong to other grounds of discrimination. With equality data, we could have sharpened the work against discrimination. I wonder if this is something that the member can at least consider supporting.

riksdagen.se

Amanda Thonander (M)

Madam Speaker! I think it is very important that the authorities have sufficient knowledge to be able to identify the risks of discrimination. Statistics is, of course, part of this.

It is also important to safeguard personal integrity. The National Audit Office points out that the authorities can use different methods to investigate the risks, but there is a certain uncertainty regarding how certain personal data may be processed. Therefore, I think it is very good that the Equality Ombudsman has been given a mandate by the government.

I think that, in any case, we should initially be a bit cautious about saying that just collecting data would solve the problem. I welcome the assignment that the Equality Ombudsman has received from the government.

riksdagen.se

Ciczie Weidby (V)

Madam Speaker! Today we are addressing the government's communication in connection with the National Audit Office's review. It contains serious criticism that should be taken most seriously.

The report's conclusion is clear: The State's work against ethnic discrimination in the authorities' decisions is not effective. The work is primarily event-driven, the authorities often lack knowledge about their operations, and the preventive work is insufficient.

The Equality Ombudsman's proactive role is also limited. Taken together, this implies a risk that people's protection against discrimination does not function as intended.

Madam Speaker! This is ultimately about trust in public Sweden. Those who apply for sickness benefit or labor market support, or who come into contact with the police, customs, or other authorities, must be able to trust that decisions are made objectively, in a legally secure manner, and without influence from ethnic affiliation, name, skin color, or origin. It is not a question of goodwill. It is a fundamental democratic principle.

The National Audit Office shows that many authorities primarily react when someone reports or complains. But discrimination is very difficult to detect for the person affected. If the authorities only wait for people to report, many problems risk remaining invisible. Therefore, a more active and systematic work was needed where the authorities themselves investigate whether there are risks and follow up on the results.

The government has given the Equality Ombudsman a mandate to support the authorities in this work. That is good, but it is not enough. Vänsterpartiet believes that further requirements are needed for the authorities to regularly carry out risk analyses and follow up on what effects their measures actually have. Work that is not measured risks becoming symbolic. Work that is not followed up risks not changing anything at all.

Madam Speaker! The report also highlights an issue that will become increasingly important in the future, namely the use of artificial intelligence and automated decision-making. More and more selections, controls, and assessments are carried out with the help of digital systems and algorithms. If these systems build upon existing biases, there is an obvious risk that discrimination is reinforced rather than countered.

Technology is never neutral in itself. Therefore, public activity must have transparency, control, and follow-up when AI is used in decisions that affect people's lives.

Madam Speaker! The National Audit Office also points out a problem that the Left Party has raised for a very long time. Large parts of the authorities' decision-making are not covered by the anti-discrimination protection that the Equality Ombudsman can exercise supervision over. This means that people can, in practice, have a weaker protection than many believe. The National Audit Office states that the government needs to take a stand on whether DO's supervisory mandate should be expanded. We share that assessment. If society is serious about combating discrimination, the legislation must provide people with real protection, and the authorities must be able to be scrutinized when there are suspicions of unfair treatment.

Madam Speaker! Discrimination harms the individual human being. But it also harms the sense of community. When people experience that they are not treated equally before the authorities, trust in our institutions and in democracy as a whole is undermined. Therefore, Vänsterpartiet welcomes that the National Audit Office has highlighted the deficiencies that exist, but we are not satisfied with merely stating the problems. We believe that the work must be intensified, that the authorities must take greater responsibility, that the scope of the Discrimination Act needs to be reviewed, and that the protection against ethnic discrimination must be strengthened. All people should be able to trust that the state treats them equally – not just in theory but also in practice.

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! I would like to ask the member a few questions. I reacted a bit during the speech. But it also concerns the member's specific statement regarding the letter. There, this matter of artificial intelligence is mentioned. I would like the member to elaborate on that a bit more. What does the member think about just this matter of AI, simply?

riksdagen.se

Ciczie Weidby (V)

Madam Speaker! As I said, artificial intelligence or any such methods do not act on their own. They are not neutral in anything. They do what they are told to do. It is in the same way as when you can ask your Chat GPT or Copilot – or whatever it is – to write something. It answers based on what the member wants answers to. In the same way, it works when one wants to use AI to, for example, screen documents of various kinds. It naturally looks for what we have asked it to look for. If one has not given the AI the right instructions, it simply continues to repeat something – that which one wanted to change.

As I said in my speech, technology is never neutral, but we must ensure that it does what we ask it to do and help us with. If it is the case that we ask it to do things incorrectly, for example based on what the Discrimination Act says or something else, we must review it and change the AI.

AI can be good for very much, but AI can also reinforce things. That was what I said in my speech. Sara Gille would have heard it if she had listened to it.

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! It is clear that I listened to the member's speech.

One cannot trust the technology 100 percent – that is absolutely true. But one must still be able to trust that the people at the authorities use it in a reliable way. That is perhaps a bit more what I am reflecting on.

Then I would like to know something regarding precisely this issue with discrimination. I will return to what I myself stated in my speech. It concerns precisely this with Swedishness and that part. We had that discussion earlier. But we also had a discussion regarding this with statistics. The member asked a bit about that. It was about how one cannot trust the statistics and what is not discrimination or is discrimination.

If several people get a job, it does not automatically mean that a certain group of people is discriminated against just because they end up in that statistic. They are grouped. That does not mean that this group is discriminated against. One actually has to look at everything. One has to look at gender. One has to look at experience. One has to look at all things in general, not just at exactly what ethnicity they have. We think it is remarkable that one can just place them into groups and that it is then like that. One should not go for discrimination as the first thing one does, but one must look at the whole.

I would very much like the member to elaborate on this, as it seems that Vänsterpartiet and the member actually think that one is discriminated against simply because one comes from a certain type of country.

riksdagen.se

Ciczie Weidby (V)

Madam Speaker! Then I have the opportunity to say what I would have liked to say in our previous exchange of remarks.

Sara Gille seems to misunderstand – consciously or unconsciously – what this review is about when it comes to grounds for discrimination. There are a certain number of grounds for discrimination, and it is those that one measures discrimination against. If Sara Gille and the Sverigedemokraterna are not satisfied with the different grounds for discrimination that exist – I know they are not, because they want ethnic Swedes to be included there – I can understand that they react. But one cannot stand and say: Sometimes there is discrimination and sometimes there is not, and this report is wrong based on different parameters. We simply do not believe in these grounds for discrimination.

It is fine. But in this review and report, one has gone through what discrimination exists based on the grounds of discrimination that we have – period. It is clear that there are groups that are disadvantaged, discriminated against, more than others. It can look different in different industries. Sometimes it is older people – 55-plus – who are discriminated against. That is a ground of discrimination. Sometimes one does not want anyone who comes from a non-European country. Then it is the ground of discrimination.

We must acknowledge whether there is discrimination or not, and we must agree on which grounds of discrimination we have. But since I and several parties with me do not agree with the Sverigedemokraterna on which grounds of discrimination exist, it becomes very difficult to continue this type of debate.

riksdagen.se

Helena Vilhelmsson (C)

Madam Speaker! I would like to take the opportunity to tell any viewers and listeners why I am wearing an orange sweater. It is because it is Orange Week, the UN's campaign to raise awareness for the fight against violence against women. If you don't have any orange in your wardrobe, I think you should get some and wear it for the rest of the week to support that campaign.

Madam Speaker! Sweden is a constitutional state. This means that every person should be able to trust that authorities make objective decisions, impartially and on equal terms. When the state makes decisions that affect people's lives – for example, regarding permits, compensations, and interventions – it should be the individual's situation that decides, not name, origin, skin color, or perceptions of which group a person belongs to. It is against that background that the Swedish National Audit Office's review of the state's work against risks of ethnic discrimination in authorities' decisions is so important.

The National Audit Office's overall conclusion is that the state's work is not efficient. That is what we have to deal with. The Centre Party's entry into the issue is clear: equal treatment should not be an ambition but is a fundamental prerequisite for the legitimacy of authorities and for people's trust in the public sector to endure.

Madam Speaker! Discrimination is prohibited by law, but apparently that is not enough. The state must also work practically to detect and reduce the risks of discriminatory decisions. This requires knowledge within the authorities, clear routines, functioning follow-up, and that responsibility does not fall between the cracks. A government's task is to ensure that this is in place.

When the National Audit Office finds that the work is not effective, there is of course reason to ask what is missing. Is there sufficient knowledge about risks of ethnic discrimination? Do the authorities follow up on what consequences their methods of work have for different groups? Is there sufficient transparency for the individual who wants to understand why a decision has been made? Are complaints and experiences from individuals used to improve the operations?

I do not think it is sufficient to provide tools to detect and identify ethnic discrimination, as the government proposes. It must also be followed by measures, including regular and routine follow-up. A legally secure system must be able to ensure that the explanation for unequal treatment is relevant differences, not unconscious perceptions or lack of routines.

Madam Speaker! For the Centre Party, the individual's freedom and legal certainty are central. The state must be strong when needed, but public power must simultaneously be limited by law, transparency, and accountability. The person who encounters an authority must be able to understand which rules apply, which tasks have served as the basis for decisions, and how they can be appealed or reviewed again. This is particularly important for people who are already in a vulnerable situation.

The person who is dependent on a government decision often has limited opportunities to personally discover or prove that something has gone wrong. Therefore, the responsibility cannot be placed entirely on the individual. The authorities must themselves have systems to find and identify risks, control quality, and rectify deficiencies.

Centerpartiet considers that the government must take the Swedish National Audit Office's criticism more seriously and ensure that the work against ethnic discrimination becomes more concrete and effective. It should be possible to follow which measures are taken, who is responsible for them, and how the results are to be assessed over time.

There is also an important difference between treating everyone equally and turning a blind eye to structural risks. If certain groups repeatedly encounter greater obstacles in their contact with authorities, the state must investigate why. Identifying such risks does not mean that one abandons the principle of individual assessment. It is a way to safeguard that principle. The risk of double discrimination is developed in our special statement, but it concerns, for example, that persons with disabilities who also belong to an ethnic minority can be affected by double discrimination.

Madam Speaker! The Riksrevisionen's audit should not be seen as an item on an administrative checklist. It should be seen as a basis for improvement. The Government and the authorities need to move from overarching ambitions to clear measures, measurable follow-up, and better opportunities for individuals to have their case reviewed.

Centerpartiet does not think it is sufficient to only give the Discrimination Ombudsman a mandate to "carry out promotional measures aimed at authorities as support in their work to investigate and manage risks of ethnic discrimination in their own operations". It is a rather long action sentence. And what does it actually say?

All people shall be able to feel security in their interaction with the state. Decisions shall be made on objective grounds. Equal cases shall be treated equally. When there is a risk of discrimination, the state shall act before trust has been lost. We will follow up the work regarding discrimination moving forward here in the Riksdag.

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! I reacted to this matter regarding double discrimination. A person can very well be discriminated against on several different grounds; I agree with that. But I question what the Center Party and the member do not like in the Sweden Democrats' motion. We are talking about this in a similar way.

riksdagen.se

Helena Vilhelmsson (C)

Madam Speaker! I do not quite know what in my speech points to that. I refer to what has been said earlier here in the speaker's chair.

The review is based on the grounds for discrimination that apply today. If the Sweden Democrats think that an additional ground for discrimination needs to be introduced, that is probably another matter than what we are discussing today.

If the member's question concerns whether groups are affected by double oppression or double discrimination, she is welcome to clarify it. I think it is quite clear that there is a risk of that. If one belongs to a group that is in a minority, there is a risk that one may experience double oppression, according to the example I gave in my speech.

riksdagen.se

Sara Gille (SD)

Madam Speaker! I am thinking about the individual perspective regarding equal treatment. We will address that in our motion. It should be equal for everyone. We want everyone to be included in this system. Everyone can be discriminated against, regardless of religion, which country one comes from, what ethnic affiliation one has, and so on.

We think it is very remarkable that one can point out certain groups covered by the grounds of discrimination but that one then cannot talk about Swedish ethnicity. If one is to mention a group, one must also mention the other groups. I think it is remarkable that some do not stand behind that because it is about equal treatment. It should be equal for everyone. I therefore find it difficult to understand it and would very much like the member to elaborate on that part a bit more.

riksdagen.se

Helena Vilhelmsson (C)

Madam Speaker! We are talking about grounds for discrimination, which per se means it is about a group of people who experience discrimination. Again: If the Sweden Democrats think that another group needs to be identified, they are free to pursue that issue, which they have also done but have not succeeded with so far.

All people are covered by workplace environment laws and laws against harassment and inequality – even Swedes. But the thing is that if one belongs to a minority, the cases can pile up so that one is hit by double injustice. I find it so difficult to see why it is a problem for Sverigedemokraterna.

All laws in Sweden apply to all persons, but discrimination can affect groups. We have anti-discrimination laws to counteract this. If it is considered that the grounds for discrimination are too few, one can work to have them expanded.

(Applause)

riksdagen.se

Veronica Kerr (KD)

Madam Speaker! Members and listeners! I would like to begin by moving to approve the Committee on Employment's proposal for a decision.

The Swedish National Audit Office's review of ethnic discrimination within state agencies is both important and urgent. It shows that there are indications that discrimination linked to ethnic origin occurs in agencies' decisions regarding support and interventions. It concerns inexplicable differences in decisions, and at the same time, much suggests that there is an underreporting. The Christian Democrats therefore welcome this review. It is important both that deficiencies are made visible and that good examples are highlighted.

One of the most interesting conclusions of the review is that only one of the reviewed authorities, Tullverket, systematically follows up on complaints regarding perceived discrimination. By analyzing complaints and searching for recurring patterns, authorities can detect problems in a timely manner and strengthen the rule of law. That approach should truly inspire significantly more authorities.

Madam Speaker! Discrimination does not always occur consciously. Stereotypical perceptions and unconscious assumptions can influence decisions. Several studies show that knowledge of these risks is often insufficient and that the work against discrimination many times lacks a sufficiently systematic approach. It is serious.

Discrimination in the exercise of public authority contravenes the principles of objectivity, impartiality, and equal treatment in the Instrument of Government. For the individual, the consequences can be extensive. People risk being treated differently, receiving poorer access to society's support, and being subjected to measures that are not justified.

Discrimination also harms society as a whole. When decisions are made on incorrect grounds, the state's resources are not used in the way the Riksdag intended. This leads to poorer accuracy, reduced efficiency, and a significantly weaker trust in our authorities.

Madam Speaker! I also want to highlight a form of discrimination that all too often falls into the shadows, namely age discrimination and ageism.

Combating ageism is an important issue for us Christian Democrats. Many older people face prejudices in the labor market despite long experience, high competence, and great work capacity. Approximately every fifth person registered at Arbetsförmedlingen is over 55 years old. At the same time, many younger people face perceptions that they lack experience and therefore should not be given responsibility or opportunities.

Every fourth Swede has personally experienced or knows someone who has experienced age discrimination. This is shown by figures from a Novus survey earlier this year. This is not worthy of a society built on the equal value of people. No one should be judged based on their age. People should be judged based on their knowledge, their merits, and their ability.

When Sweden needs more people in work, we cannot afford to let prejudices stand in the way. We need to take advantage of the experience of older people while simultaneously giving younger people the opportunity to establish themselves and grow. Therefore, the work against discrimination must also include a clear effort against ageism.

Madam Speaker! The Equality Ombudsman has an important role in the work against discrimination, but today the authority devotes a relatively limited part of its activities to bringing individual discrimination cases to court. The Christian Democrats believe that this needs to change.

Those who are subjected to discrimination shall not stand alone. The Equality Ombudsman should to a greater extent actively pursue fundamentally important cases and provide the individual with stronger support.

Strong protection against discrimination requires not only legislation but also that the law is tested and upheld in practice. When discrimination has legal consequences, both the rule of law and the trust in society's institutions are strengthened.

For the Christian Democrats, the starting point is clear. All people have the same inviolable human dignity. No one shall be discriminated against on the basis of ethnicity, religion, gender, disability, sexual orientation or age. The state shall be a role model in the work for equal treatment, the rule of law and respect for every person's dignity.

riksdagen.se

Bassem Nasr (MP)

Madam Speaker! The National Audit Office has examined how the state works against ethnic discrimination in administrative decisions concerning individuals. Among other things, it has examined Arbetsförmedlingen, Försäkringskassan and Skatteverket. These are authorities that play a major role in people's lives every day.

The National Audit Office's conclusion is that there are deficiencies and that the work is simply substandard. It mentions, among other things, that it is inefficient and event-driven and that there are deficiencies in the preventive work. This is serious criticism. The National Audit Office recommends, among other things, increased competence, regular follow-up, and internal development of the work against discrimination.

From the Green Party's side, we stand fully behind these recommendations. We will always stand up for dignity, legal certainty and equal rights.

Madam Speaker! Being equal before the law must go in both directions. Immigrants have the same obligations as everyone else to pay taxes, to follow laws and regulations, and to provide information to authorities. However, immigrants have not had their rights met in the same way. From the Miljöpartiet side, we see that this is an injustice that not only harms individuals but also harms social cohesion and trust in democracy. Miljöpartiet believes that it is not enough for the obligations to be equal – the rights must also be equal.

The state must lead and set an example here. It is about Swedish law applying equally to everyone. It is also about safeguarding our democracy.

Democracy can be about going and voting every four years, but every day the lives of Swedes are affected by agency decisions on, for example, parental leave, preschool places, or family reunification. If people perceive these decisions as fair, trust in democracy increases. That is why the officials who work at the agencies and make these decisions have been called the guardians of democracy. To all officials at agencies all around our country, I want to say the following: Thank you for providing information every day, answering questions, making assessments, and making legally secure decisions! Thank you for protecting our democracy!

In the Green Party's statement, it mentions intersectionality. What does intersectionality mean? The concept was coined by Professor Kimberlé Crenshaw, who studied American legal cases from the 70s. One of these legal cases concerned Emma, who was denied a job at a car factory because she was a Black woman. She sued the car factory, but the court sided with the car factory and argued that it was not a case of discrimination. The court argued that the car factory did not discriminate against women, as white women were employed in administration. Nor did the car factory discriminate against Black people, as Black men worked in production.

The court failed to see that different grounds for discrimination can interact, reinforce each other, and increase the vulnerability of individuals. Professor Crenshaw likened this to a crossroads – hence the term intersectionality. The word therefore comes from the English "intersection", which means crossroads.

For Miljöpartiet, the intersectional perspective is central in this work. All people, regardless of grounds for discrimination, shall have the same rights.

Miljöpartiet supports the committee's report.

The deliberation was hereby concluded.

(Decisions were made under § 14.)

riksdagen.se

Source: The Swedish Parliament. The speeches come from the open data of the Riksdag, translated into English by AI, which may contain errors.
Portraits: Photo: The Swedish Parliament. (opens in a new tab)